Proposed Annual HIPAA Security Risk Analysis Requirements
HHS has proposed that covered entities and business associates review, verify, and update their Security Rule risk analysis at least every 12 months and whenever relevant changes occur. Here is what that would mean for an independent practice, and what to do while it is still a proposal.
PROPOSED RULE — NOT YET FINALWhat the Security Rule requires today
The Security Rule requires an accurate and thorough assessment of the potential risks and vulnerabilities to the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of electronic protected health information (45 CFR §164.308(a)(1)(ii)(A)). The current rule text does not set a fixed review interval. HHS guidance treats risk analysis as an ongoing process that should be updated as your environment changes.
What HHS has proposed
More specific documentation
The risk analysis would need to be written down in more detail, including the assets reviewed and the risks identified.
At least every 12 months
The analysis would be reviewed, verified, and updated at least once a year.
When things change
An update would also be needed when relevant changes occur in your environment or operations.
Changes that should prompt an update
- A new or replaced EHR, billing system, or other software that handles ePHI.
- A new office, remote work arrangement, or major change to your network.
- New devices, or a change in how ePHI is stored, sent, or backed up.
- A new vendor or business associate with access to ePHI.
- A security incident or near miss.
Does this mean a new outside assessment every year?
Not automatically. As proposed, the requirement is about keeping the analysis current, verified, and documented. Many practices will still choose qualified outside help, particularly for the first thorough analysis, but a new third-party assessment each year is not what the proposal, as described by HHS, would automatically require.
Risk analysis, risk management, and compliance audit are different
Risk analysis
Identifies where ePHI lives and what threats and vulnerabilities could affect it. This is the document HHS proposes to review at least every 12 months.
Risk management
The ongoing work of reducing identified risks to a reasonable and appropriate level (45 CFR §164.308(a)(1)(ii)(B)).
Compliance audit
A separate proposed requirement to audit compliance with the Security Rule at least every 12 months. It checks whether safeguards are in place, not just what the risks are.
What to keep on file
Scope of the analysis, a list of systems and devices that touch ePHI, threats and vulnerabilities considered, likelihood and impact ratings, the resulting risk levels, planned corrective actions, and the date, reviewer, and outcome of each review.
Why an accurate assessment matters now
An annual update is only as good as the baseline it updates. A thorough analysis today shows you which safeguards to prioritize, such as multi-factor authentication, encryption, and backups, and gives you something concrete to maintain if the proposal is finalized. HHS OCR has also repeatedly cited missing or incomplete risk analyses in HIPAA enforcement.
Sources
- HHS proposed rule fact sheet
- Federal Register notice, 90 FR 898 (January 6, 2025)
- Federal Unified Agenda, RIN 0945-AA22
- HHS risk analysis guidance
- 45 CFR §164.308
This page is general information about a proposed rule, not legal advice. Check the final rule text when HHS publishes it.
Want help turning these proposals into a practical plan for your practice?
Schedule a HIPAA Consultation →