ePHIJournal · Vol. 01 · The Independent Practice Issue

A Records Request. A $140,000 Settlement.

OCR’s 56th Right of Access enforcement action offers a practical privacy lesson.

November 2026 · Regulatory information checked November 3, 2026 · Read the full issue

A request for patient records is routine office work. But an alleged failure to provide access can lead to an OCR investigation that examines a practice’s underlying HIPAA procedures.

The Shen Smiles case

On October 8, 2026, HHS OCR announced its 56th Right of Access enforcement action, a $140,000 settlement involving Pennsylvania dental practice Shen Smiles. The matter arose from a complaint alleging failure to provide timely access to protected health information. OCR also identified potential deficiencies concerning Privacy Rule and Breach Notification Rule policies and procedures.

The case was resolved by agreement. It is important to distinguish potential violations resolved in a settlement from findings established after litigation. The enforcement announcement also references an assertion involving stolen records; that should not be transformed into a confirmed, separately adjudicated breach.

Know the response clock

Under the HIPAA Privacy Rule, covered entities generally must act on an individual’s access request within 30 calendar days. One additional 30-day extension may be available if the entity gives the required written notice within the initial period. These are outer limits, not suggested waiting periods; many requests should be completed sooner.

A practical access-request workflow

  • Record the request date, identity-verification steps and the records requested.
  • Assign a responsible person and track the deadline, even if an EHR vendor helps fulfill the request.
  • Use written, tested procedures for the requested form and format, permitted fees and any lawful denial.
  • Document what was provided and when, and provide a compliant extension notice when justified.

The takeaway: HIPAA compliance is not only cybersecurity. A practice also needs reliable processes for patient rights, privacy administration and workforce responsibilities. Training and written procedures should make those processes routine.

Scroll to Top