ePHIJournal · Vol. 01 · The Independent Practice Issue
The Fight to Remain Independent
How reimbursement, administrative pressure and the proposed HIPAA Security Rule are changing the economics of smaller medical practices.
REGULATORY STATUS | PROPOSED — NOT CURRENT LAW · HHS PLANNED FINAL ACTION: JULY 2027
Current HIPAA rules remain in effect. Check the live HHS agenda and Federal Register for changes before relying on the NPRM details in this dated issue. View official HHS agenda
From the editor: a useful starting point
This introductory issue is written for independent practices navigating HIPAA today—and evaluating the changes HHS has proposed. Independent practices deliver something that large systems cannot always replicate: continuity, local accountability and a personal relationship between physician and patient. But preserving that independence requires managing costs, technology and compliance responsibilities that compete with time for patient care.
This inaugural issue focuses on decisions an office manager or physician can actually make. You will find an evidence-based explanation of the proposed HIPAA Security Rule, a practical distinction between an IT security scan and a regulatory risk analysis, real enforcement and breach cases, and a checklist for evaluating your own program. The editorial standard is simple: What is required? Why does it matter to a smaller practice? What should the practice do next? We believe responsible urgency comes from facts, not fear.
For generations, independent medical practices have allowed physicians to build personal relationships with patients, exercise clinical judgment and remain connected to the communities they serve. But the business of remaining independent is becoming more difficult.
A changing practice landscape
According to the American Medical Association, the share of physicians working in private practice declined from 60.1% in 2012 to 42.2% in 2024. That is a decrease of nearly 18 percentage points in 12 years—not a claim that 18% of practices closed, but a striking shift in where physicians work.
The AMA surveyed physicians whose private practices had been acquired and asked which factors mattered to the sale. Better negotiating power with payers was important or very important to 70.8%; access to costly resources to 64.9%; and managing payers’ administrative and regulatory requirements to 63.6%. These statistics are about broader business pressures, not specifically HIPAA.
Where HIPAA fits
HIPAA is one component of an accumulating administrative burden. A hospital network may have dedicated information security personnel, a privacy office, legal counsel and project managers. In a ten-person physician office, the same office manager may handle billing, scheduling, staffing, patient complaints, vendors and security paperwork. The obligations do not disappear because the practice is small. And when responsibility is fragmented among the physician, an IT vendor and an office manager, the most dangerous question can be the simplest one: Who is actually making sure our HIPAA requirements are being met?
More than an IT expense
Compliance is sometimes treated as a software purchase or an annual training certificate. In reality, the Security Rule requires a continuing program of identifying risks, implementing safeguards, evaluating effectiveness and documenting decisions. Good software helps; it cannot replace management responsibility.
The financial challenge is therefore not just equipment and subscriptions. It is the time required to understand the practice’s environment, organize evidence, train staff and follow through on corrective work.
A manageable path forward
The most important first step is an accurate understanding of where your practice stands.
What is required today
The HIPAA Security Rule already requires an accurate and thorough risk analysis of potential risks and vulnerabilities to the confidentiality, integrity and availability of electronic protected health information (ePHI). It also requires risk management and a security awareness and training program. These are not obligations reserved for hospitals. An EHR vendor’s assurances, a vulnerability scan or a purchased policy binder may be useful components, but none automatically establishes that the practice has evaluated all of its ePHI risks. The practice must understand the scope of its own systems and vendors.
What could change next
HHS published proposed Security Rule amendments in January 2025. Among the proposals are more detailed written risk analyses; updates at least every 12 months; role-specific annual security awareness training; annual compliance audits; inventories and network maps; and more explicit technical safeguards and testing. The changes are proposed, not binding law. The agency’s Unified Agenda lists final action planned for July 2027. The proposal may change before finalization. But waiting for a final rule does not solve existing gaps. Practices with an incomplete risk analysis or undocumented training already have work to do under today’s rules.
The answer is not an overnight overhaul
The workable starting point is to understand the current environment. A thorough security risk analysis (SRA) can identify where ePHI is handled, which risks are most significant and which safeguards need attention. Training can help personnel recognize threats and understand their responsibilities. Together, these can form a foundation for a prioritized risk-management plan—not a substitute for the other safeguards already required.
Five first steps
- Establish your baseline. Determine whether your existing SRA reflects today’s systems, workflows, vendors and threats.
- Identify and prioritize deficiencies. Address urgent risks and document a reasonable corrective-action plan.
- Train your workforce. Cover relevant HIPAA responsibilities, provide practice-specific instruction and retain evidence.
- Assign ownership. Name who will coordinate the work, review completion and elevate unresolved risks.
- Review and improve. Revisit risks after incidents, technology changes and changes in practice operations.
You do not have to solve every problem today. But you do need to know where you stand—and begin addressing the problems that matter.